Skip to Content

How to Appeal an OER, NCOER, AER

Today we’re going to discuss how to appeal an evaluation report to include a relief for cause report.

Preliminary Steps Before Filing an Appeal

If you are considering an appeal, you should have already taken or considered taking the following actions:

  • Discussing the issue with your rating chain
  • Requesting a commander’s inquiry, if that’s appropriate
  • Following an Article 138 complaint, if that is appropriate
  • Following a claim of reprisal, if that’s appropriate—you would file that with the IG

Note: You can see that we have a video on how to file a commander’s inquiry and how to file an Article 138 complaint.

If any of these reports come back in your favor—the inquiry, the Article 138, claim of reprisal, or a 15-6—you can use all of that information in your appeal.

Types of Appeals

  • Administrative Issues
  • Issues Associated with Content
  • Both Administrative and Content Issues

Questions to Consider Before Filing an Appeal:

  • Did the rating chain use your support form to prepare the evaluation report?
  • What errors or omissions work in your favor?
  • Did they give you credit for everything you did well?

Reference Materials

  • AR 623-3 will help you understand what can be appealed.
  • DA PAM 623 will walk you through the specific process of developing your appeal.
  • Raider Quick Evaluation Software and The Evaluator (available from Mentormilitary.com) provide checklists, examples, samples, and step-by-step guidance on how to prepare your appeal.

Steps to Take Before Filing Your Appeal

  1. Control Your Emotions & Focus on the Facts
    • Don’t allow your emotions to cloud your judgment.
    • Find an honest broker—someone you trust who can assist you through the process.
    • Look for someone in your unit or external to your unit, such as a mentor or previous supervisor, who is articulate and well-versed in the regulations.
  2. Seek Assistance from:
    • The IG or JAG to assist you as well.

If you need help preparing or rebutting a relief for cause, preparing a commander’s inquiry, or appealing an evaluation report, contact me using my email address in the description below.

Administrative Review of the Evaluation Report

  • Does it contain any errors?
  • Is the ACFT information correct?
  • Are the duty title and duty description correct?
  • Are the rated/non-rated months correct?

Examples of Administrative Errors That Work in Your Favor

  • If a report records six months of rated time and three months of non-rated time, but the correct number should be three rated and six non-rated, this is something you want corrected.
  • If you can argue that three months was not enough time to make a reasonable assessment of your performance, this could strengthen your appeal.

Who Can Appeal?

  • The Rated Soldier
  • Third Parties (Limited to specific entities):
    • G-1 Human Resource Command
    • Office of the Surgeon General
    • JAG Office of the Chaplains
    • National Guard Bureau

Other individuals with knowledge can contact one of these points of contact listed above and they can appeal on your behalf.

What Can Be Appealed?

  • Unproven derogatory information
  • Incorrect non-rated time
  • New information that significantly impacts a previously submitted report
  • Proven personality conflicts when they resulted in an unjust report

Army Special Review Board & Promotion Consideration

  • If your appeal is approved, the Army Special Review Board will determine if promotion consideration is warranted due to the changes in the report.
  • If the report was significantly changed, you may be reconsidered for promotion.

Commanders’ Responsibilities

  • Ensure soldiers receive assistance in preparing and submitting appeals.
  • Provide soldiers with a copy of the rating scheme.
  • Include all relevant documents in the appeal package.

What Cannot Be Appealed?

  • Counseling Sessions – These alone are not grounds for an appeal, but they can be used in conjunction with other supporting documentation.
  • Failure to Process in Sequence – If a rater processed reports out of order, this is not grounds for an appeal.
  • Statements from Rating Officials claiming administrative oversight or typographical errors are not sufficient for an appeal.

Timelines for Filing an Appeal

  • Appeals must be processed within three years of the through date of the report.
  • The likelihood of a successful appeal diminishes over time.
  • Appeals filed after three years must be sent to the Army Board for Correction of Military Records.

Processing & Decision Outcomes

  • Processing times vary depending on:
    • Complexity of issues
    • Age of the report
    • Other relevant factors

Possible Appeal Outcomes

✔ Approved (Whole or in Part)
✔ Denied (Memo Filed with the Evaluation Report)
✔ Denied? You can submit new evidence for reconsideration or escalate to the Board of Corrections for Military Records.

Priorities for Appeals

For Officers:

  • Priority 1:
    • Passed over twice for promotion
    • Mandatory retirement within six months
    • Selected for release from service within six months
  • Priority 2:
    • Not selected for promotion at least once, but no mandatory release within six months
  • Priority 3:
    • All other appeals

For NCOs:

  • Priority 1:
    • Passed over twice for promotion in the primary zone
    • Mandatory retirement within six months
  • Priority 2:
    • Not selected for promotion at least once, but no mandatory release within six months
  • Priority 3:
    • All other appeals

Burden of Proof Lies with the Soldier

  • Soldiers must present clear and convincing evidence.
  • Gather and submit appropriate documentation, including:
    • Third-party statements
    • Statements from the rating chain (if applicable)

Steps in Processing an Appeal

  1. Decision to Appeal
    • Do you have the evidence to support your appeal?
    • Have a disinterested third party (IG or JAG) review the report.
  2. Prepare the Appeal
    • Develop rationale
    • Collect supporting evidence & documentation
    • Gather third-party & rating chain statements (if applicable)
    • Clearly identify what is being appealed & the action requested
  3. Submit the Appeal
    • Ensure all submission requirements are met
    • Identify the correct priority level for your appeal

Summary

  • Who Can Appeal
  • What Can & Cannot Be Appealed
  • Timelines & Processing Priorities
  • Burden of Proof
  • Steps for Developing & Submitting an Appeal

✅ Thank you for joining us. Until next time, stay safe and stay healthy!

George N.