Skip to Content

4–10. Evaluation Report Appeals Priorities

Appeals are processed in the order of priority established by the HRC Evaluation Appeals Branch.

The Evaluation Appeals Branch will assign the level of priority for all evaluation appeals and notify appellants of the priority level upon preparation and forwarding appeals to the ASRB Agency.

Appellants are responsible for notifying the Evaluation Appeals Branch of any change in their status that would affect the priority.

The Evaluation Appeals Branch will coordinate with the ASRB to establish priorities and update appropriately when priority levels require change based on Department of the Army mission requirements.

Paragraphs 4–10a and 4–10b represent example priorities for use as a guide on how levels of priority are determined.

a. Officers appealing DA Form 67–10 series or DA Form 1059 series.

(1)

First in priority are appeals pertaining to officers who—

(a)

Have been twice nonselected for promotion and given a directed discharge, release, or mandatory retirement date within 6 months.

(b)

Have been selected for release within 6 months by an HQDA elimination board or an AGR continuation board.

(c)

Have been recommended for elimination within 6 months.

This also applies to officers who have applied for and have been denied voluntary indefinite category.

(d)

Have been notified for eligibility of an HQDA selection command board within 6 months.

(e)

Appeal related to sexual assault or sexual harassment violations.

(2)

Second in priority are appeals pertaining to officers who—

(a)

Have not been selected for promotion at least once but who do not have a mandatory release date within 6 months as a result.

(b)

Are on a pending promotion list removal as stated in AR 600–8–29.

(3)

Third in priority are appeals not eligible for higher priority.

b. Noncommissioned officers appealing DA Form 2166–9 series or DA Form 1059 series.

(1)

First in priority are appeals pertaining to NCOs who have been—

(a)

Twice nonselected for promotion in the primary zone of consideration and are within 6 months of discharge, release from service (expiration term of service), or mandatory retirement date.

(b)

Selected for release under the HQDA Qualitative Management Program or ARNG or USAR Qualitative Retention Program.

(c)

Selected for release from AGR by an AGR continuation board.

(d)

Identified for referral within 6 months to an AGR continuation board.

(2)

Second in priority are appeals pertaining to NCOs who have been nonselected for promotion in the primary zone of consideration at least once, but who do not have a mandatory release date within 6 months.

(3)

Third in priority are appeals not eligible for higher priority.

Referenced Paragraphs

4–10a

Paragraphs 4–10a and 4–10b represent example priorities for use as a guide on how levels of priority are determined.

4–10b

Paragraphs 4–10a and 4–10b represent example priorities for use as a guide on how levels of priority are determined.

AR 600–8–29

Are on a pending promotion list removal as stated in AR 600–8–29.